Credit Unions OnlineCredit Unions Online
Credit Unions Online
FRONTLINE Investigates the Massive Consumer Loan Industry

FRONTLINE Investigates the Massive Consumer Loan Industry

FRONTLINE will present The Card Game on PBS channels nationwide November 24, 2009. In The Card Game, a follow-up to the Secret History of the Credit Card and a joint project with The New York Times, FRONTLINE correspondent Lowell Bergman and the Times talk to industry insiders, lobbyists, politicians and consumer advocates as they square off over attempts to reform the way the industry has done business for decades. A comparison of banks and credit unions will be part of the documentary.

As credit card companies face rising public anger, new regulation from Washington and staggering new rates of default and bankruptcy, Bergman investigates the future of the massive consumer loan industry and its impact on a fragile national economy. "The card issuers could do anything they want," Robert McKinley, CEO of CardWeb.com, tells FRONTLINE of the industry's unchecked power over consumers.

"They could change your interest rate. They could impose an annual fee. They could close your account." High interest rates along with more and more penalty fees drove up profits for the industry, Bergman finds, as the banks followed the lead of an aggressive upstart: Providian Bank. In an exclusive interview with FRONTLINE, former Providian CEO Shailesh Mehta tells Bergman how his company successfully targeted vulnerable low-income customers whom Providian called "the unbanked." "They're lower-income people-bad credits, bankrupts, young credits, no credits," Mehta says.

Providian also innovated by offering "free" credit cards that carried heavy hidden fees. "I used to use the word 'penalty pricing' or 'stealth pricing,'" Mehta tells FRONTLINE. "When people make the buying decision, they don't look at the penalty fees because they never believe they'll be late. They never believe they'll be over limit, right? ... Our business took off. ... We were making a billion dollars a year." It took the economic collapse in the fall of 2008 to set the stage for potentially historic change in the consumer credit business. President Obama and his team pushed through a credit card reform bill in May, and they're now looking to establish a new Consumer Finance Protection Agency. But the banking and financial services industries contribute huge amounts of money to Congress -- and the jury is still out on whether the new regulations can pass.

"It's a step in the right direction, but it's a modest step," says Harvard law professor Elizabeth Warren. "It's a set of very discrete new laws. And the credit industry instantly set to work on how they could run around them. By itself, that set of rules won't change the game." "It's hard for them to get a bill through the U.S. Senate when the industry is pouring money into Washington," says Martin Eakes of the Center for Responsible Lending of the banks' political clout. "As Sen. [Dick] Durbin from Chicago recently said, 'The banks, even as unpopular as they are right now in this crisis, still own this place.'" For complete details on the upcoming episode, visit FRONTLINE's Website.

by Staff Writer
Published November 10, 2009
comments powered by Disqus
Find a Credit UnionCalculatorsHoliday ClosingsBlogInterest RatesBest Credit UnionsLargest Credit Unions
A Better Way to Bank? There's a Credit Union for That.℠
FacebookTwitter
What is a Credit Union?Privacy PolicyTermsAbout UsContact Us
Credit Unions Online, Since 1995. ©2017CommonBond- All Rights Reserved.